Excel or Software for Manpower Payroll? An Honest Guide
We sell software, so weigh this accordingly. Excel is the right tool for many small manpower companies. Here is how to tell when it has stopped being one, and how to move without betting a salary month on it.
- Excel is enough while one person can hold the whole month in one file, on one or two sites.
- The trouble is not Excel's arithmetic. It is the typing, the copies of the file, and the one person who understands it.
- Software earns its cost when timesheets no longer have to be typed, and when the owner can see how a total was made.
- Move by running one salary month both ways and comparing the two results, worker by worker.
What Excel does well
Excel is on every office computer, everybody can use it a little, and it will do anything you ask. A manpower supply company with fifteen workers on one site can run its timesheet, its salary sheet and its document dates in three tabs, and it would be wrong to tell that company it needs more.
If that is you, take our free files and carry on: the timesheet format, the payslip and the document expiry tracker.
Where it starts to hurt
Excel rarely fails at arithmetic. It fails around the edges, in ways that grow with the number of workers and sites.
Everything is typed, and typed twice. The supervisor's sheet is typed into a timesheet for the customer. The totals are typed again into the salary sheet. Each typing is a chance for a different number.
The file has copies. "Timesheet Nov FINAL", "Timesheet Nov FINAL 2", and the one on the manager's laptop. Which one did the salaries come from?
One person understands it. The file grew over years in one person's hands. When that person is ill in the last week of the month, nobody is paid on time. When that person leaves, the company's memory leaves too.
Anyone can change anything. A rate overwritten by accident looks exactly like a rate that was meant. Excel does not say who changed a cell, or when.
Everyone sees everything. The person who types timesheets has the salary tab one click away.
Nothing warns anyone. A visa date in a spreadsheet is silent until somebody opens the file and happens to look.
A fair comparison
| Excel | Software made for manpower supply | |
|---|---|---|
| Cost | Already paid for | A setup cost and a running cost |
| Getting started | Today | Days to weeks, with your data moved in |
| Bending it to your way of working | Total. It does what you build | Within what it offers, or what the seller will change for you |
| Timesheets | Typed by hand | Imported from Excel, or read from a photo and checked |
| Salary from hours | Formulas you maintain | Worked out the same way every month |
| Who sees salaries | Whoever has the file | Decided by role |
| Who changed what | Unknown | Written down |
| Document expiry | Colours, when someone looks | A message before the date |
| The bank salary file | Assembled by hand each month | Made from the approved salaries |
| If the key person is away | The month is at risk | Someone else can follow the steps |
Excel wins the first three rows, and for a small company those three can outweigh the rest.
Seven signs you have outgrown it
- Typing the month's timesheets takes more than a day.
- A salary was wrong last quarter because of a typing mistake.
- You have found two versions of the same month.
- The owner approves the salary total without being able to check it.
- A document expired although its date was in the tracker.
- The bank file was rejected because a total did not match.
- Month-end depends on one person not being ill.
One of these is an annoyance. Three of them is a pattern, and the new rule that wages are due on the first of the month makes each of them cost more than it used to.
What to ask before you buy
Sellers of payroll software, ourselves included, show the same pleasant demo. These questions get behind it.
- Does it work from our supervisors' sheets, or do our supervisors have to change? Software that needs every site worker to carry an app is a different project from one that reads the paper you already have.
- Is it made for pay by the hour? Most HR systems assume a fixed monthly salary and treat hours as an extra.
- Can it make the salary file our bank wants? Ask to see the file, not a slide about it.
- Who can see salaries? Ask to be shown the screen of a junior member of staff.
- Can we get all our data out, at any time, in a form we can open? If the answer is slow, the answer is no.
- Who moves our existing workers and rates in? Typing two hundred workers into a new system is a month nobody has.
- What if we need something it does not do? Some sellers change the product for a customer; many do not.
- What does it not do? A seller who can answer this quickly knows the product.
How to move without risk
The fear is reasonable: salaries are the one thing a company cannot get wrong. So do not switch. Overlap.
- Move the lists first. Workers, rates, customers and sites go into the new system, from your Excel files.
- Run one month both ways. Do the month in Excel exactly as always. Do the same month in the new system.
- Compare worker by worker. Every difference has a cause: a typing mistake in Excel, a rule the software does not know yet, a rate that was out of date. Each one you find is a problem you would have had anyway.
- Pay from the method you trust. In the overlap month, that is still Excel.
- Switch when a month matches. Then keep Excel for one more month as the check, and stop.
Pick a quiet month for this, not the one before a holiday.
Questions people ask
Can a manpower supply company run payroll in Excel?
Yes, and many small ones do it well. It works while one person can hold the month in one file. It becomes risky as workers and sites grow, because of retyping, copies of the file, and dependence on one person.
How many workers before Excel becomes a problem?
There is no fixed number. Sites matter more than workers: thirty workers on one site are easier than thirty on six. The signs above are a better test than a head count.
Is software safer than Excel for salary data?
It can be. Good software decides who sees salaries by role, records who changed what, and backs itself up. A spreadsheet sent by email does none of those. Ask the seller to show each of the three.
How long does it take to move from Excel to software?
The lists can be moved in days. Trust takes one or two salary months, run both ways and compared. Plan for that overlap; it is what makes the move safe.